The Regional Impact of Brexit – Assessing the Government’s ‘EU Exit Analysis’

The part leaking to the press of the Government’s EU Exit Analysis – Cross Whitehall Briefing[i] highlighted the dire consequences for many parts of the UK of leaving the EU in the June 2016 referendum. The leak and its handling also exposed the extreme reluctance of the Government to provide the information necessary for informed public debate. The Government asked the civil service to investigate three scenarios: Remain in the single market; A free trade deal with the EU; No deal.  The public have been denied the opportunity of properly assessing for themselves these three outcomes, since no details have become available about the assumptions, methodology or data used in arriving at the impacts on GDP summarised in Table 1 (below).

In the light of the above we would draw attention to the study of the regional and sectoral impact of Brexit, commissioned by the Federal Trust and undertaken by Dr Andrew Black (Senior Fellow at the Global Policy Institute). This study considers four scenarios which cover tariff impacts, the impacts of lower investment and consumption for each sector, and their related multiplier effects. The assumptions behind the results are made clear as are the data sources and the input-output methodology.

The lack of details for the Government study makes comparison difficult. However, Dr Black’s study shows some marked divergences from what we know of the government study. His study shows:

  • rather less variation between regions under all scenarios, so even the South-East is hit hard
  • rather worse outcomes for 7 of the 12 regions, while Wales, the East of England and the North East do better in the government study
  • far worse outcomes across the board in the worst case scenario; also different rankings (Table 2).

Hard Brexit and the Regions by Dr Black was published in November 2017 and is available HERE or HERE.

See also:

Andrew Black, Hard Brexit, international trade and the WTO scenario, May 2017, The Federal Trust

 

Table 1 Government study: Variation in growth rates compared to an unstated baseline model in % of the baseline figure)

RegionSingle MarketFree TradeNo dealNo dealrank
East Midlands-1.8-5.0-8.56
Eastern-1.8-5.0-8.05
London-1.0-2.0-3.51
North East-3.0-11.0-16.012
North West-2.5-8.0-12.0=10
South East-1.5-4.5-7.54
South West-1.0-2.0-5.02
West Midlands-2.5-8.0-13.0=10
Yorkshire and Humberside-1.5-5.0-7.03
Northern Ireland-2.5-8.0-12.012
Scotland-2.5-6.0-9.07
Wales-1.5-5.5-9.58

1 = least impact

Source: Guardian 8 February 2018

 

Table 2 Dr Black’s worst case scenario

Percentage change in gross output

Region%Rank
East Midlands-15.3011
Eastern-13.786
London-10.511
North East-13.272
North West-14.7310
South East-13.353
South West-13.454
West Midlands-14.649
Yorkshire and Humberside-14.568
Northern Ireland-15.5912
Scotland-13.735
Wales-13.947

1 = least impact

[i] Jessica Elgot, Heather Stewart and Peter Walker ‘Revealed: the £80bn. cost of hard Brexit’, The Guardian, 8 February 2018.

About the GPI

The Global Policy Institute is a research institute on international affairs. It is based in the City of London, and draws on both a rich pool of international thinkers, academics as well as policy and business professionals. The Institute gives non-partisan guidance to policymakers and decision takers in business, government, and NGOs.

Upcoming Events

august

No Events

september

201917sep5:00 pm7:00 pmThe EU and Russia: What kind of neighbours?5:00 pm - 7:00 pm Mary Sumner House, 24 Tufton Street, SW1P 3RB Event Organized By: Global Policy Institute, Federal Trust & Konrad Adenauer Foundation London

october

201903oct9:00 am11:00 amHuawei, 5G and the China Cyber Threat9:00 am - 11:00 am University House (Liverpool Street), 109 Middlesex Street, London E1 7JF Event Organized By: Global Policy Institute, Blenheim Strategy & Federal Trust

201915oct5:00 pm7:00 pmBrexit Update5:00 pm - 7:00 pm Mary Sumner House, 24 Tufton Street, SW1P 3RB Event Organized By: Global Policy Institute & Federal Trust

Categories

X